And other news from the AW Board of Education
Outgoing Anthony Wayne Board of Education member Shellie McKnight, who is resigning effective Dec. 31 after two years in office, shared some parting thoughts during her final meeting on Dec. 8.
First, she thanked Superintendent Kevin Herman, Assistant Superintendent Kevin Pfefferle, Treasurer Kerri Johnson and Technology Director Chris Hamady for their professionalism, then spoke about the importance of public education.
“Public schools are the hub of the community,” McKnight said. “It is indeed the foundation of our American democracy.”
McKnight warned of what she calls “unwarranted attacks on public education at the statewide and federal level” that seek to weaken public schools for private education vouchers that take away funding from schools, including Anthony Wayne.
“Please educate yourself on this growing menace and try to stop it,” she said.
McKnight also shared a concern for what she sees as an increase in religious intrusion during the school day, which she called a “clear violation of separation of church and state.”
As she cleared her belongings in preparation for moving to Colorado, McKnight said she found Anthony Wayne memorabilia from her daughters, who both graduated from the district.
“We talked about how fortunate we were to live in an excellent school district. I will be truly sorry to leave this,” McKnight said.
Because her effective resignation date is Dec. 31, the board must follow strict state policies and appoint her replacement between Jan. 10 and 30, said Board Vice President Jeff Baden. Last month, the board received 25 applications for those seeking to fill her position. Of those, four finalists – Amy Barrett, Katie Carollo, Matthew Culling and Troy Schalitz – introduced themselves to the audience. Read more about them here.




Two community members, Sara Fournier and Roy Collaco, addressed the board about their hopes for the process of selecting McKnight’s replacement.
McKnight, Fournier said, “brought deep knowledge of public education, did her homework on legislation affecting Ohio schools, and consistently showed up informed,” as she represented 4,000 voters who put her into office two years ago.
Fournier asked whether the board has a rubric with defined scoring, weighting and question alignment to areas being evaluated for each of the four finalists. Items that would support clarity include: which competencies are being scored; questions being asked during the interviews; and how the scoring will be documented and compared consistently.
“These safeguards strengthen the integrity of the process. They clarify decision making, build trust and protect the board from claims of inconsistency or preferential selection. Families want confidence that decisions about curriculum, policy and budgeting are based on the needs of all students rather than alignment and affiliation,” Fournier said.
Collaco shared how, during the COVID-19 pandemic, he was hospitalized for three weeks and nearly died. He noted that the board at the time made decisions on health and safety protocols from the Centers for Disease Control, National Institutes of Health and Toledo Lucas County Health Department to protect the staff, students and community.
“I’m grateful that the school board…set aside their personal opinions and relied on experts,” he said. “They withstood a wave of anti-science attacks.”
The board, he said, is elected to champion and advocate for the educational interests of all children based on the latest laws, best recommendations of trained experts and empirical, validated research, not to implement their personal ideology.
“The school board and school buildings are not the proving ground for anyone’s political ambitions or spiritual redemption,” Collaco said. “If you can’t make that distinction, then you should skip the school board and run for political office instead, where one can claim to be an expert in anything and everything.”
During the meeting the board also:
–Congratulated the girls volleyball team, which was the state runner up in Division 2 for the second year, finishing the season with a 26-2 record. Coach Chrissy Graven said that four of the five graduating seniors have signed to play at the next level, and two players had back-to-back All-Ohio honors. Even more impressive, Graven said, is the 4.0 GPA first quarter team average. Graven thanked the community for the support throughout the season.

-Congratulated 2024 graduate Lillian Albert and senior Ruby Rapp for receiving the Principal’s Award and Superintendent’s Award (respectively) as part of the 2025 FOCUS Art Show. Teacher Carrie Flagg said the FOCUS Art Show is held at Toledo Museum of Art and features the best artwork from students throughout Northwest Ohio.

–Named Kyle Miller as president pro-tem for the first meeting of 2026, which will be held on Tuesday, Jan. 13 at 6 p.m.
-Approved a farm lease agreement with Keith and Michael Hannewald, at a price of $160 an acre, for 2026-2028.
-Passed a resolution of urgent necessity for the chilled water line repair at Waterville Primary, for $54,483. Issue found while on site.
-Approved a $1,038,433 contract with Spatco Energy Solutions to replace the fuel tanks, pumps, dispensers and other associated equipment. The 40-year-old tanks – including a 6,000-gallon gas tank, a 10,000 diesel tank and another 12,000 diesel tank – have exceeded their useful life and have had water leaking in, said Operations Director Neil Raymond. The new tanks will be installed this summer.





































