PUT-IN-BAY – Though I’ve lived in Northwest Ohio since 2018, only this summer did I decide to make the relatively short journey to the party-right-of-passage destination of this region: Put-in-Bay (South Bass Island). It was Pyrate Fest, Saturday, June 28, when my family and I decided to make a day of it, donning our hastily put-together pirate gear.

I had read that Pyrate Fest was a family friendly event, but also knew from plenty of informants that Put-in-Bay can be a wild ride, filled with drunken debauchery. As it turns out, both things can somehow be true! Here’s what our experience was like.
Miller Ferry is one of two options for getting to the island (the other is Jet Express). If you plan on bringing your car to the island, Miller Ferry is the only option. For this trip, we were offered free tickets to this ferry (find their regular pricing here) and we opted not to take our vehicle, as we knew we had a golf cart from E’s Put-in-Bay Golf Carts reserved for us as well.
Pyrate Fest/Other Events
We found a seat upstairs along the balcony where we could catch a nice breeze and people watch on the packed vessel, which was filled with families and pirates ready to party alike. We spoke to one such Pyrate Fest attendee from Powell, Ohio : Rachael Weis. It was her first time in Put-in-Bay, but she came fully prepared with a sword at her hip and a parrot on her shoulder.
“I’m here with some friends that have a condo on Marblehead. So they invited a big group of us to come up and enjoy the weekend,” Weis said, adding that she was most looking forward to seeing the diverse group of musicians that can be found at the local restaurants and bars during events like this.
“I think it’s just a cool event. I’m not really into pirate stuff, but we all wanted to dress up because it seemed like a way to get the spirit of the island,” she said.

I expected Pyrate Fest to be in a concentrated area on the island, but because the island is so small – it’s 3.7 miles long and 1.5 miles wide – the festivities were everywhere we went. From the moment we departed the ferry to pick up our golf cart to the end of our visit when we’d circled the island at least five times, we found pirates everywhere.
Even if you have to wait until next year for this event, there are several other events coming up during the warmer weather months. They include:
- Annual Labor Day Bash at the Bay (August 29-September 1)
- Put-in-Bay Historical Weekend (September 5-7)
- Downtown Art at the Park (September 6)
- Halfway to St. Patrick’s Day (September 13)
- Vintage Sports Car Racing (September 16-18)

I found the scene at Put-in-Bay to be a nice balance between partying, family fun, and educational activities. Obviously, you won’t have to look hard to find a local watering hole with live music and delicious food, but you will also find a delightful playground in the center of town, which our son Townes very much enjoyed; a nice selection of ice cream shops; easy access to beaches for a swim; and historical sites aplenty.

South Bass Island Lighthouse
One of the latter wasn’t far from where the ferry dropped us off: the South Bass Island Lighthouse, owned by The Ohio State University’s Stone Lab. We spoke with one of the Stone Lab field station assistants, Claire Beasley, about the history and ecology of this site.
“The Ohio State University is the only university in America to own a lighthouse,” Beasley said. “Construction started on this lighthouse in 1895, and it was running and in use until 1962 when the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, or NOAA, put in that tower over there, which is our automated lighthouse.”
I climbed the rather steep staircase up to the top of the lighthouse to meet my husband (Matt) and our four-year-old son (Townes), where we had an excellent view, including the nearby Green Island. It is off limits to visitors because it acts as a wildlife preserve for birds and the Lake Erie Water Snake.
“You can find them [the Water Snakes] on the Marblehead Peninsula over by Sandusky and up those rivers somewhat, but they do have a very small native range, to the point they were actually listed as endangered, but were removed from that federal list in 2011,” said Beasley.

She said the snakes were endangered for two reasons: one of their food sources – the mudpuppy – was endangered, and water quality worsened.
“One of the researchers who used to be with us, Dr. Kristin Stanford, is now over at the Ohio Department of Natural Resources. She did a lot of work with the water snake, did population surveys, and she also did a lot of work with the public to educate them about the snakes, because they’re not exactly charismatic.”
For anyone who is interested in learning more about these snakes, check out this Dirty Jobs episode with Mike Rowe, in which he works with Stanford to study them. He gets bit. A lot.
Heineman’s Winery
In the height of the summer heat, an indoor tour is sometimes called for, and there is none better than the Crystal Cave at Heineman’s Winery, the home of the World’s Largest Geode. We bought tickets to tour the cave – a brief, but spectacular tour – along with tickets to tour the winery and get samples (a grape juice made on-site for the minor). Two tours, plus wine/juice samples, for two adults was $30.

Heineman’s wine, which you can order at the bar or purchase by the bottle, can be enjoyed in their charming courtyard. It was a fun diversion before getting back to our tour of the island.
Taking this trip to Put-in-Bay made me realize that there’s this subculture of lake island life that I had previously not tapped into. We’ll definitely go again soon, while also adding Kelly’s island and other lakeside stops to our bucket list before the warm weather fades.
*This trip was partially funded by Miller Ferry and Visit Put-in-Bay.












































