After having rushed to countless scenes to help people in the snares of tragedy, two Toledo-area residents became victims.
Charlie Adair, 45, and Ron Lumbrezer, 64, were both struck by cars and killed last year.
Adair, a volunteer firefighter, had stopped to assist crews in a car crash Oct. 28 when a passing vehicle struck her.
Lumbrezer was hit Jan. 11, 2011 while he was crossing the road in front of his house.
Lumbrezer’s son, R.J., and Adair’s husband, Craig, planned a community track meet April 29 at Holy Trinity School. Tickets are $5, or 5 for $20, for a full day of dashes, runs, relays and mother/daughter and father/son competitions. There will be tug of war, baseball
throwing and hitting competitions, a corn hole tournament and a foul shooting contest.
Various fire departments will also play a tug of war for donations to their department and the Charlie Adair and Ron Lumbrezer Memorial Fund.
The Fulton County Sheriff’s Department will attend to fingerprint kids and the North Star BHP Steel company will discuss safety and demonstrate to children the differences between candy and medicine.
“It’s not just a track meet,” Craig Adair said. “It’s more a family get-together and have fun day and that’s what she would always want to do.”
Following Adair’s love for children and involvement with the Holy Trinity, the memorial fund will be split up among scholarships for students and teachers.
Present or future students who need financial help to attend the school will be eligible for scholarships from 75 percent of the memorial fund. The other 25 percent will go toward a teacher’s assistance fund, R.J. Lumbrezer said.
Adair taught sixth grade, coached volleyball and helped struggling kids get through their homework in tutoring sessions. She had started talking about wanting to become a volunteer firefighter in 2001.
Always known for getting things done, Adair made it happen a few years later. She was a volunteer firefighter for about six years, Craig said.
“If there was more of her in the world it would be a lot better place,” he said.
Lumbrezer also had a history of serving. He was in the National Guard and also the Metamora Fire Department years ago. He then worked in the insurance business for more than 40 years, starting with Prudential and later owning and operating Lumbrezer-Malone Insurance Agency until 2008.
He served musical tastes too. Lumbrezer played guitar in his band Sound Garden for 25 years. The group played covers of many genres, including country, pop
and rock, for weddings and other formal events. They also played for square dancers.
R.J. said the funeral was packed, with a two-and-a-half-hour wait to see the casket.
“He was very well-liked,” he said. “He was very good with people and it didn’t matter who you are, Dad could identify with you regardless of social differences on any end of the scale.”
April 22 Yell & Tell rally places focus on child abuse
When Yell & Tell: Stop Child Abuse Now, Inc. had its first rally in 2004, founder Pamela Crabtree wasn’t sure it’d ever have another. However, years later, the organization is planning its ninth rally.
“We’re not going anywhere. We’re not a threat to any of the big guys. We want to work in concert,” Crabtree said. Her group will have its ninth annual Yell & Tell: Stop Child Abuse Now Rally on April 22 at the Walbridge Park Shelter House. April is also National Child Abuse Prevention Month.
The first rally took place in Washington, D.C., and due to high costs, Crabtree wasn’t positive it would happen again. At her family’s encouragement, however, she brought the rally to Toledo where it has flourished. Throughout the years, keynote speakers have included Congresswoman Marcy Kaptur and State Rep. Teresa Fedor.
“Each year, since 2005, we have grown in stature and respect,” Crabtree said.
This year, University of Toledo head football coach Matt Campbell will give the keynote speech and Becky Shock of 93.5 WRQN will emcee the rally. For entertainment, the Distinguished Clown Corps and soloist Amy Gibson are set to perform.
Several local groups including Lucas County Children Services, Family and Child Abuse Prevention Center and Mercy Health Partners will be on site with more information. In addition, the Lucas County Sheriff’s Office will provide fingerprinting of children and give parents the records, Crabtree said. A silent auction gives eventgoers a chance to bid on Toledo Mud Hens tickets, car services and other prizes. Children will also receive a coloring book in English or Spanish that outlines inappropriate touching.
Crabtree, a survivor of abuse, was inspired to start her group after an experience on an Internet message board that she frequented with other survivors. The message board would occasionally get posts from young people who said they were being abused. Crabtree knew she had to do something.
“I got to the point where I posted a message where I said, ‘We’ve got to do more. We need to walk the walk,’” she said. “We have to tell [the children] to yell immediately. They have to yell and tell.”
Crabtree did not come forward with her story until she was in her mid-40s. “I did not feel comfortable telling anyone because I thought I had done something dirty. I was oblivious to the fact I was a victim of a crime,” she said. Crabtree also wrote a book based on her experiences “The Gift of Hurt,” available at www.pamelacrabtree.com.
“I know now of the importance of survivors, be it boys or girls, to come forth immediately,” Crabtree said, adding that some survivors can become depressed or turn to substance abuse so getting help is crucial.
Society should work toward ending child abuse and make sure to report cases of suspected abuse, Crabtree said. The average amount a family pays in taxes because of child abuse is $1,460 annually, she added.
“If you don’t want to go strictly for the compassionate side of helping kids because you’re afraid to report the abuser … Well, then look at the figure that’s taken out of your budget each year,” Crabtree said.
Some people don’t report suspected child abuse because they fear separating families, which is a misguided notion, Crabtree said.
“I can tell you that the police, Lucas County Children Services or any other child protection order, they don’t want to go in there and pull that child out; they want to help that child,” she said.
In 2011, Lucas County Children Services received 4,148 referrals of suspected child abuse involving 6,046 children. The agency learned that 587 area children were abused or neglected. Thirty-two percent of children served stayed in their own homes, 31 percent lived with a relative, 32 percent were placed in foster care and 5 percent went to a group home or private institution.
Crabtree also recommended that guardians keep open lines of communication so children feel comfortable talking to them. Parents and adults should also be careful to observe signs of child abuse such as changes in sleep patterns or even pregnancy.
In addition, parents should be certain it is safe to leave children with the parent’s boyfriend or girlfriend before doing so.
“Once we can protect our children, the ripple effect will be mammoth and we can stop child abuse, that’s something we do have control of,” Crabtree said.
The free rally is 1 p.m. April 22 at the Walbridge Park Shelter House on Broadway Street, across from the Toledo Zoo. For more information or to donate, visit www.yelltell.org. To report a case of suspected child abuse, call (419) 213-CARE.
Victims of underreported crimes sought
She blamed herself.
She was 18. She was at a friend’s house drinking beer. She started getting so tired she could barely keep her eyes open. She remembered her friend leaving the room with a partner, leaving her alone with a man she hardly knew. Then, nothing.
She awoke the next morning naked. In bed next to the man she hardly knew. Fumbling to get dressed and still feeling woozy, she fled the room before he awoke. She never saw him again. But she hasn’t completely recovered nine years later. She doesn’t think victims really ever do.
Days later, her so-called friend approached her and admitted she had drugged her drink. She was too uptight about men, her friend told her, so this friend figured she’d make things a little easier.
Sharon (not her real name — Toledo Free Press does not identify rape or sexual assault victims) was “uptight about men” because she was molested as a child.
Victim blaming
Even still, Sharon said she fell victim not only to a man, but to her own self-doubt.
“Victim blaming — it is a huge reason why victims do not come forward and it starts long before the victim goes to court,” said Deborah Stoll, director of the YWCA H.O.P.E. Center. “Many people believe and accept the myths of rape. We accept as truth that somehow the victim is responsible for what happens to her; that she shouldn’t be out at night, shouldn’t be drinking, she shouldn’t flirt, she shouldn’t be wearing certain kinds of clothing.”
Fearing that type of reaction, Sharon didn’t talk to her friends or family. She did not report the rape to the police. She worried that she would get in trouble for underage drinking.
“At the time, I didn’t completely understand that it was rape,” she said. “I felt like I had that drink, I wasn’t able to say no, so if i didn’t say no was that really rape? In my mind, that was the process I was going through. It took me a while to come to the conclusion that what happened to me wasn’t my fault.”
It took nearly five years. One of Sharon’s friends had a similar experience and came to her to talk. Sharon found herself repeating to her friend that it wasn’t her fault. That she shouldn’t feel guilty. That she was a victim. And then it clicked.
“If I feel this way about her then why am I so hard on myself?” she wondered.
Reassuring a victim in the same way Sharon did to her friend is one of the most important offerings toward recovery you can make, Stoll said.
Reporting
Reporting a rape is intimidating, Sharon said. There’s the courtroom experience, in which the defense sometimes alleges a victim’s history of flirting or promiscuity or blurs the line as to whether the victim provoked sexual activity between herself or gave tacit consent to the alleged rapist. And prior to that, victims fear being charged with falsifying a police report if his or her story has any holes or discrepancies, Sharon said.
Fifty-four percent of sexual assaults are not reported to the police. And 97 percent of rapists will never go to jail, according to the National Crime Victimization Survey. Nationally, nine out of 100 rapes end up in prosecution.
According to the City of Toledo’s 2010 Annual Report, 140 rapes were reported in 2010.
That was down from 165 the year prior. The clearance rate in 2010 was reported at 34.3 percent, down from 37.6 percent the year before.
Sharon started volunteering at the H.O.P.E. Center a few years ago. She said she wished she would have used some of the services following her incident but that she feared to come forward.
The center will participate in the Victims’ Rights Survivor Night on April 25 with the goal to reach out to more men and women who have yet to seek aid.
The H.O.P.E. Center has a 24-hour crisis line, often used by individuals who have been raped in the past and are facing the depression, the insomnia and eating disorders after the assault. The organization also has a program that sends an advocate to emergency rooms to talk to victims who share what their options are if they want to report to the police. The center also has support groups for the victims. There are about 160 victims a year.
Misconceptions
Sharon grimaces when thinking about the common perception that rape victims are typically accosted by “that guy in the bushes” or in a “dark alley.”
Her assailant was an acquaintance. About two-thirds of rape victims across the country also know their aggressor, according to the Rape, Abuse and Incest National Network. Stoll has a theory as to why misconceptions about rape still exist despite the data.
“We believe them for self protection; if we say we can protect ourselves by not going out at night or watching where we park then we feel safer,” Stoll said. “And I think it also is why we point fingers at victims and we look for things that they did wrong so we can avoid those pitfalls.”
Going Global: Cause for encouragement
It has been painfully slow to come, but it does appear to be coming. I’m talking about an economic recovery. And, thankfully, this economic recovery includes Toledo and Northwest Ohio. For the first time in more than three years, there is genuine cause for encouragement.
There are some hard facts on employment that are difficult to refute. Unemployment in the Toledo Metropolitan Statistical Area is beginning to decline. Last year at this time the unemployment rate for the Toledo area was 10.1 percent; today it is 9.3 percent and slowly declining. While 9.3 percent is still much too high, we can be encouraged that it is moving in the right direction. Equally encouraging is the larger employment picture in Ohio. February brought decreased unemployment rates in 65 of Ohio’s 88 counties and a statewide reduction in the seasonally adjusted unemployment rate from 8.9 percent last year to 7.6 percent.
There are additional hard facts on exported goods and services that were reported in the March 25 Toledo Free Press, “Brookings Institution: Toledo economy improving.” These figures on the growth of Toledo exports alone give us reason to be even more optimistic. According to the Brookings Institution, Toledo “is now ranked third among the nation’s top 100 metro areas for export growth from manufacturing contributions.” This could very well be the new beginning of an important growth sector of Toledo’s economy — global trade.
There are many more subjective factors that give cause for encouragement. Among the most important is the leadership role of Mayor Mike Bell in exploring and attracting foreign investment in the Toledo region. This is a new role for Toledo’s mayor and one that we want to applaud and encourage. Foreign investment is critical if our city and region are to successfully compete with other progressive cities. Enlightened cities around the world are actively, even energetically pursuing foreign direct investment. Mayors must play a leadership role in these efforts if cities are to be successful in attracting international investment.
The mayor cannot do this alone. It requires a concerted, coordinated and collaborative effort from the region’s economic development agencies and organizations. I’m more optimistic today about our region’s economy than in previous years because of the growing levels of cooperation and collaboration among these agencies and organizations. At a recent event on international trade I overheard the leader of one of our economic development organizations refer to himself and his colleagues as the “Mayor’s team.” This is cause for encouragement.
Then there are the Toledo-area business leaders who are venturing into the global marketplace with their goods and services. This can be a daunting venture for first timers and even veterans of international marketing. There is much to know about international markets, business and trade policies, and cultural practices that vary considerably from country to country. I am also pleased and encouraged that our area institutions of higher education — University of Toledo, Bowling Green State University, Lourdes University and Owens Community College — are stepping up to the plate by offering courses and programs to help prepare newcomers to international marketing.
At UT the College of Business and Innovation is providing special training for those who want to break into the rapidly growing international markets through its program, Global Target. In addition, most of UT’s colleges — Pharmacy, Engineering, Medicine, Law and others — are expanding their outreach and engagement to include foreign countries through recruitment of international students, study abroad, faculty exchanges, and collaborative research. These efforts and the UT’s new strategic plan for global initiatives will be strongly supportive of the role Northwest Ohio will play on the global scene.
Those who have traveled to India, China, the Middle East, Africa and elsewhere know we have only scratched the surface of this opportunity. There is a vast global market for Toledo products and services waiting to be appropriately tapped.
For these and many other reasons, we have cause for encouragement as we look ahead to the remainder of 2012 and beyond. Are we out of the woods yet? Not quite, but we are headed in the right direction.
(For information on Global Target, contact [email protected])
Dan Johnson is director of global initiatives, president emeritus and distinguished university professor of public policy and economic development at the University of Toledo. Email him at [email protected].
Survivor Night offers help and hope to victims
A collection of leaders from local and state victims’ rights organizations are teaming to educate Toledo’s victims about resources that might lift them from the clutches of hopelessness.
Victims’ Rights Survivor Night will begin at 5 p.m. April 25 at the 911 Training Center on Jefferson Avenue. Until 7 p.m., those affected by crimes from rape to homicide to bullying can visit booths hosted by state and local agencies to learn where and how they can seek help. The free event will also feature a performance by the Toledo Youth Choir and presentations by the Victims of Crime Compensation and the Victim Information and Notification Everyday (VINE).
The idea is to make the confusing process of seeking aid more accessible, as well as to reach out to individuals who do not know what programs can help them, said Russ Simpson of Parents of Murdered Children.
Simpson and his wife, Pat, lost two of their four children to murder.
“In this field, everyone is protecting their little piece of the pie; we want to put down that line, like, ‘I have to protect my program, you have to protect yours,’” said Lynn Carder, program coordinator with the Victim Witness Assistance Program through the prosecutor’s office. “But the bottom line is that we have to provide services to the victims and when you gather everybody together, you’re much more likely to find someone that can help.”
By forming a coalition, the groups can guide more traffic to programs that are underutilized. Simpson said a lot of people are unaware that they might qualify for state funding to cover funeral expenses after a homicide. Or they might not realize that the government runs a victim notification program that tracks a perpetrator’s movements through the different steps of the legal processes. VINE alerts the victim when that perpetrator moves to different facilities or is up for parole, among other actions.
“So many people fall through the cracks,” Simpson said.
Falling through the cracks is easy if there are no formal charges made or if the victim’s aggressor is not indicted by a grand jury, never found or if the crime is a misdemeanor. Victims in these situations don’t end up in the system that puts them in touch with Carder’s program, so she is unable to educate them about their options, she said.
Events like Survivor Night helps to fill those cracks.
“Come on down and ask for services. It doesn’t make any difference whether the crime happened 15 years ago — there are people out there who haven’t seen help for 10 years,” Simpson said.
Cindy Dugan lost her son nearly four years ago. Matthew, known as a gentle and loving jokester with a deep, contagious laugh, was shot in 2008 at a BP station in Toledo. He was the store clerk at the time.
Her son’s killer Anthony Belton was sentenced to death this month.
Dugan uses VINE to easily track developments surrounding the convicted man. She also had the help of victim advocates during the trial.
“It would have been a lot more frightening without that and I don’t think I would have been able to carry on for as long as I did,” she said. “I would have felt very overwhelmed and very lost in the whole process.”
Victims’ Rights Survivor Night attempts to reach out to those who haven’t reported their crimes. She said she understands why people are intimidated by the justice system.
“All I can say is for people to be patient and strong,” she said. “It’s endurance — one day at a time. That’s the way we did it. We thought, ‘Oh, this would be the last day we go to court month after month after year after year.”
Woodberry: The facts about who saved Scott High School
“Just the facts, ma’am.”
— Joe Friday, “Dragnet” 1951–59
— Warren Woodberry,
Scott High School, class of 1956
Those on the March 17 tour of the newly renovated, nearly 100-year-old Scott High School witnessed a reminder of how history can be left out or altered. The new principal of Scott began by asking those present, starting with the class of 1940, to raise their hand. Before they could be acknowledged, a voice rang out from the side of the room with the following question: “What about the class of 1930?” The voice belonged to Martin, the son of 93-year-old Doris Sing Hedler, who was in the class of 1936. Ms. Hedler was in the honor society and was the baccalaureate chairperson for 1936. When I interviewed her she described how the old school looked in her day and how thrilled she was that it was renovated, not torn down.
Here are some economic costs for 1936:
- Average cost of new house: $3,925.
- Average wages per year: $1,713.
- Cost of a gallon of gas: 10 cents.
- Average cost for renting a house: $24 per month
- One loaf of bread: 8 cents.
- One pound of hamburger meat: 12 cents.
- Studebaker car: $665.
- Ladies Swimsuit: $6.95.
Just as Ms. Hedler was almost overlooked before her son spoke out, it is important to speak out and acknowledge those who really led the fight to save Scott High School from the wrecking ball. It was brought to my attention that in various newspaper articles and statements, Scott alumni are often given the back seat or not mentioned at all in the history of the fight to save Scott. The members of the Scott Alumni Association, under former president Robert Davis and spurred by Coach Ben Williams, began the fight to save Scott from the wrecking ball. Others, including the Old West End Association and Save Our Scott, came on board at a later date and played an equal role in strengthening the Scott alumni fight to save the school. It was not house parties that saved Scott. It was attendance at meeting after meeting and constant correspondence and appeals to the Toledo Public Schools Board of Education, the mainstream media, the Ohio State Facility Commission, Joyce Barrett of Heritage Ohio, and many other supporters, politicians and Scott alumni.
Credit must be given to The Toledo Journal and its education writer, Bob Stiegel, who wrote stories while some other papers were negative about the value of saving Scott and those who fought this battle. Also, the role of former TPS board member Darlene Fisher can never be diminished in the eyes of the those who fought, as she was there from Day One. Although her name, and many others, are completely absent from some articles about who saved Scott High School, those involved know the valuable role she played. People have a right to their opinions of who saved Scott High School but they do not have a right to ignore the leadership of the Scott Alumni Association.
A little history: Once, the Ohio State Facility Commissioner, Michael Shoemaker, received letters from members of the Scott Alumni Association (all of which I have archived) concerning their efforts to save Scott. A visit was arranged through TPS for him to visit Scott. After the building inspection, Mr. Shoemaker declared the building sound and strong, and stated that his commission would allow for renovation if the additional funds could be found.
The TPS board, under then-president Steve Steel, the Scott Alumni Association under president Robert Davis, and the public united behind the levy, which resulted in the $42 million renovation of Scott High School. Saving Scott resulted in saving the oldest high school in Toledo, recognition by historic preservationists throughout the United States, and the tradition of the nearly 100-year-old school was allowed to continue into history. Now the family legacy can continue. Also making history is Treva Jeffries, Scott’s first African-American principal, which would not have happened without the struggle waged by the Scott Alumni Association. Like the “Trail of Tears,” there are two sides or more to every story, but the fact of who lead the fight to save Scott only has one side and that story can be found in the body of this column.
On March 13, Toledo City Council recognized members of the Scott Alumni Association and its supporters who fought to save Scott by issuing a proclamation by City Councilman Tyrone Riley, a member of the Scott Alumni Association.
“Once a Bulldog — Always a Bulldog.”
“Just the facts, ma’am.”
Warren Woodberry is a community activist and Scott High School alumnus.
Historic-themed dinner set for Vistula House
Toledo’s Vistula District is inviting you to take a step back in time for a dinner party.
Set in the dining room of the 1865 Vistula house, the feast will be served surrounded by decor representative of the Victorian era. Among 14 course options, highlights will include teriyaki-style salmon with rice pilaf, a filet of beef with mushroom demi-glace and Cornish game hen a l’orange.
The house will host three dinners, all starting at 6 p.m., April 26-28, 2012. Ten people can attend each evening. Tickets cost $100 a person and can be reserved by calling (419) 389-3452.
Proceeds will go to the Historic Vistula Foundation, a nonprofit that aims to preserve historical properties.
The Vistula District predates Toledo’s incorporation and includes large homes, smaller dwellings, corner stores and ethnic churches.








