43.4 F
Toledo
Friday, April 4, 2025

Subscribe

Home Blog Page 5

Automata from the mind of Will Gerhardinger

0
William Gerhardinger tests his hand automaton. Gerhardinger ran strings through the digits of the hand he fashioned from wood and attached the strings to a drum with programable slots to control how the hands moves. (TFP Photos/Stephen Zenner)

TOLEDO — With a swift crank, Will Gerhardinger activated the input mechanism for his homemade wooden calculator. 

“This is my calculator. It’s a little big, but it doesn’t need any batteries,” he said, introducing the device.  

On his YouTube channel What Will Makes, an in-depth video made by Gerhardinger explains the intricacies of the geared system he made to automate the mathematic processes of addition, subtraction, division and multiplication.

“I can remember my mom saying I should just make it a shorter video,” Gerhardinger recalled after his first video featuring an automaton hand with a runtime of over 10 minutes. “‘Just talk about this one aspect of it.’ But in my mind, what makes it so interesting is that all these different parts come together into the one object.”

Ignoring the advice from his mother, the 22-year-old college graduate jam-packed nearly 35 minutes of information into the explanatory video, and he was pleasantly surprised to find an audience of over 175K tuning in to find out about the wooden mechanical device based off of a 19th century arithmometer. 

Gerhardinger was just trying to communicate what he found interesting about the mechanism and didn’t anticipate the warm reception from his online audience. 

William Gerhardinger, 22, of west Toledo, inspects a 50mm 1.8F Pentax Super-Takumar lens in his room inside his parents’ home in Toledo, Ohio on Monday February 10, 2025.

“Simply incredible,” read one of the 1,089 comments under the video from the user @aghauler1964. Aghauler1964 continued, “Im an amature [amateur] horologist, Im simply amazed, not only that you created this machine, but you also described its function and theory.”

But for Gerhardinger, the function and theory are inseparable parts to the final product.

“I think there’s something about the length [of the video] that people actually like,” he said, and qualified the statement by saying his viewers, at least, don’t mind a deep-dive. More than just showing how the device works in the video, Gerhardinger walks his viewers through the making of the device. 

The video combines mechanically complex problem solving with a DIY woodworking presentation, but Gerhardinger also voices over the physical process with historical analysis and philosophical musings.

In his calculator gears and levers represent to Gerhardinger a physical solution to a conceptual problem. Looking behind the curtain, the kinetic movement of the mechanism explained how people hundreds of years in the past approached mathematics. 

“There’s something so simple about the causality of mechanics…on the basic level it’s so simple, it’s just like, thing-hits-thing.”

When building his own arithmometer, Gerhardinger simply looked at past ones, without a tutorial or plans. 

The inside mechanisms of the wooden calculator made by William Gerhardinger, 22, of west Toledo, in Toledo, Ohio on Monday February 10, 2025. Gerhardinger made his own hand-crank calculator based off of a 17th century design by Gottfried Leibniz called the Stepped Reckoner.

“Because it’s mechanical, I knew I could understand how it’s going to work,” he said. “I dabble in electronics, but it’s not as interesting to me because you can’t see how it’s working.”

There’s a sort of magic when you see a mechanical computer working that you can begin to understand what it’s doing, just by looking at it.”

The project of building the calculating machine has been eight years in the making, but Gerhardinger began the project as a curious freshman in high school investigating his interests.

Unsurprisingly, Will’s father, Joseph Gerhardinger, is a retired mathematics teacher who taught at Notre Dame Academy, and Will’s grandfather, Will’s namesake, was a tool and dye maker for Sealed Power, an automotive repair parts supplier.

“My dad (William) was very mechanical,” said Joseph Gerhardinger. “I think he would have been very intrigued,” by his grandson’s work.

Will Gerhardinger first began revealing his mechanical ability around three or four years old when he started taking the switches for lamps in his parents’ home. In another instance early indication of his mechanical prowess the young Will mimicked his father by taking the cover off of power outlets with a screwdriver. “My wife and I quickly learned we had to limit his exposure to tools until he learned safety protocols,” Joseph Gerhardinger said.

Until junior high, Will’s father was unsure if he could follow through on his aspiring projects, but then he automated an old bicycle left around the house.

“He actually hooked up the trigger for the drill switch to the front brake…you’d press the front brake, and that would cause the drill to power the bike,” Joseph Gerhardinger recalled. 

Engineering seemed to be an obvious career trajectory for Will, but after taking an engineering course in high school he found engineering to be too narrow of a field for his creative mind. Instead, Will opted for a liberal arts education from Kenyon College, studying history and especially falling in love with the history of technology.

“I was briefly an intern at a museum in New Jersey, a really cool museum called the Morris Museum that houses a lot of automata and music boxes,” Will said. “That was very cool.”

William Gerhardinger is hand-to-hand with his wooden hand automaton. Gerhardinger ran strings through the digits of the hand he fashioned from wood, and attached the strings to a drum with programable slots to control how the hands moves.

Like he had done before, Will observed the mechanisms in the museum, and decided to implement his own automaton mimicking the figure and movements of a hand, with strings and a programable drum serving as the controller for the hand’s fingers. 

The hand automaton would serve as the subject matter for Will’s first video on YouTube with significantly less explanation, less complexity in the design and less viewers than his calculator video. This first foray into video was a good test vehicle for the more widely appreciated calculator project. 

“I kind of unintentionally became an artist,” Will said, after relaying that some people had mentioned putting his creations into an exhibition. Intentionally, Will crafted every solution he reasoned into reality with poplar wood.

“There’s an honesty to it,” he said about cutting and shaping the gears, bevels and a chain out of wood by hand.

“There’s almost a care put into the object,” he added. “And I think watching the video, you appreciate that, because you see me making it [the object]. But the thing and [the process of] making it is… they’re inseparable.” 

Less sentimental people badgered Will in the comments under his video about the process he was implementing, asking why he hadn’t 3D printed the parts for his mechanical device.

“Even though it would be a lot quicker to program a computer to spit it out in a 3D printer, there wouldn’t be any big connection that people would feel, or that he would feel,” Joseph Gerhardinger said, knowing his son. “Part of what makes it [Will’s work] accessible [is that] people can see how this complex gear mechanism works…but also the fact that you [or anyone] could make it with hand tools or power tools.”

A wooden dangling figure made by William Gerhardinger.

You can imagine yourself painting, because you can understand the process. There’s a brush and there’s oil paint or pastel, or watercolor, whatever, but you can see a human hand made this. And that’s why standing in an art museum and looking at a painting is more moving to people than looking at a reproduction that was printed.”

A comment section full of praise reassured Gerhardinger of his instinct. 

“I assumed this was laser cut and was already impressed,” said @thethoughtemporium. “Then I saw the scroll saw. Then it slowly dawned on me you built the whole thing with hand tools **out of wood** no less, and my jaw dropped.”

The internet has embraced Gerhardinger’s authenticity to himself, perhaps because Gerhardinger presents a return to a friendlier, more personal approach to thought and creation.

“Him making it [the calculator] out of wood was the most fitting thing I’ve ever seen, because we were working with metal in the labs all the time,” said Andrew Smith, the lead mentor for Gerhardinger’s robotics team at St. John’s High School.

“Metal was everywhere,” in the robotics competition, according to Smith, but Will would insist on his own volition to make prototype parts out of wood.

Will would always go home, hand carve it [the piece for their robot] out of poplar wood and then come back and go, ‘Hey guys, I thought of this neat idea of how we could solve this problem we ran into. Let’s go ahead and try this piece of poplar wood that I’ve carved.’”

Andrew Smith

Perhaps it is also unsurprising that one of Will’s uncles is a cabinet-maker.

From the woodworking to the mechanics, philosophy to the video, Will has really only sought to explain himself and his love for what he was making.

“People would ask me what I’m doing, and I would kind of get overwhelmed with trying to answer the question,” Will said. “The answer is so big, and I realized that I can’t ask this person to sit down for a half hour [to] listen to me talk about all this, but I could make a video representing all of it.”

And so he did.

Will has been happy to find out through his YouTube channel that his creative ability and love of mechanical technology has an audience.

Will said he has a few projects in the hopper, as far as YouTube is concerned. But for now, he does not have any hard deadlines on when they will be finished.

Presently, Will is working at a clock repair shop, putting his mechanical prowess to good use. For the past number of months he has been apply to graduate programs, and recently Will was accepted into the graduate fellowship with the Winterthur Program in American Material Culture: Studying the History and Philosophy of People and Their Things, at the University of Delaware. Will plans to accept the fellowship with the Winterthur Program at the University of Delaware.

William Gerhardinger removes the number plate to his hand-crank calculator. Gerhardinger made his own hand-crank calculator based off of a 17th century design by Gottfried Leibniz called the Stepped Reckoner.

The inside mechanisms of the wooden calculator.

William Gerhardinger holds The Portable Blake, a collection of William Blake’s writings. A graduate of Kenyon College with an undergraduate degree in the history of technology, Gerhardinger combines philosophy with the purposes behind his mechanical creations.

Steven J Athanas: Luck o’ the Irish

0

Happy St. Patrick’s Day!

Toledo Rockets defused by Ball State

0
Toledo native Kendall Carruthers goes up for a wide open layup as Ball State can only watch.

Story by Max Alfonso | Photos by Kyle Brown

CLEVELAND – Going into the locker room during halftime, No. 2 Toledo women’s basketball team was up by three points and feeling confident they could knock off No. 1 Ball State to claim the MAC Championship at Rocket Arena on Saturday.

The Toledo bench reacts to a three-point shot.
The Toledo fans held onto hope throughout the tournament, showing unwavering support all season long.

After all, the Rockets put down Ball State 70-66 the last time they met nearly a month ago.

But Toledo blew the half-time lead, and Ball State outlasted Toledo 65-58 behind a 4th quarter 14-point surge by forward Alex Richard, who finished the game with 28 points and nine rebounds. She had help by point guard Ally Becki, who stuffed the stat sheet with 12 points, five assists and seven rebounds, helping to earn the Cardinals their first MAC Championship title since 2009.

Richard was named to the All-MAC Second Team and Tournament Team, along with Becki, who was crowned the MAC Player of the Year and was First Team All-MAC, as well as the tournament MVP.

This is the second straight year Toledo will not make the NCAA tournament. The Rockets made it to the Big Dance two years ago under Tricia Cullop, who left after 16 seasons to take the head coaching job at the University of Miami (Florida).

Toledo head coach Ginny Boggess directs a play from the sidelines as Toledo regains possession.

After three seasons at Monmouth, Ginny Boggess was hired to replace Cullop and will likely continue her first year with an invite to play in the Women’s Basketball Invitation Tournament (WBIT). Both selection shows are on Sunday, March 16.

In the media room after the game, Boggess said she was proud of the entire roster and how far they have come as team.

“I’m really excited that because of our work in the regular season, this won’t be the last time these two wear this jersey,” Boggess said, referring to Sammi Mikonowicz and Khera Goss, who were sitting next to her. Both seniors were named to the All-MAC tournament team.

Sammi Mikonowicz crashes hard to the floor during a layup attempt. The play resulted with a foul on Ball State’s Alex Richard.

Championship game notes

For all three tournament games, Toledo’s Nan Garcia, named 6th MAC Player of the Year, was moved into the starting lineup, replacing Jessica Cook. Garcia responded with back-to-back games of double-figure scoring. But in the championship game, Garcia had five turnovers, was blocked several times under the net, and finished with only three points, making only one of her eight shots.

Toledo’s Jessica Cook, center, reacts to a foul she received.

Toledo found a bit of success with Cook, who made all four of her shot attempts to finish with eight points, but found herself in foul trouble with four fouls.

Toledo native Kendall Carruthers led the way for Toledo with 17 points, making seven of her nine shot attempts.

Rossford’s Mikonowicz and Goss combined for 19 points for Toledo.

Toledo’s Sammi Mikonowicz shoots over Ball State’s Madelyn Bischoff as power forward Evalyse Cole watches.
Sammi Mikonowicz reacts to a foul during a layup from Ball State’s Marie Kiefer, 14.

After the game, Boggess pointed out that second chance points were a big turning point in the game. Toledo had five and the Cardinals had 11.

“I told them when I took the job that their legacy is already cemented with the three championships,” Boggess said, talking about her seniors. “If they teach these young kids how to win, then their legacy will live on. Our future is because of them buying in and letting us do our jobs.”

When the season concludes, Toledo will lose five key pieces from a team that has won a lot of big games and an NCAA tournament game over Iowa State in 2023. It was the first Rocket win in the NCAA tournament since 1996. 

“I’m really grateful for what the Toledo provides us, to create that elite student athlete experience. We’ve got something really special here,” Boggess said.

Toledo men lose in semifinal

No. 4 Toledo men’s basketball lost to the No. 1 seeded Akron in the semifinal Friday night with a score of 100-90. They finished the season with a 18-15 record, their eighth consecutive season with a record over .500.

The men have won the MAC regular season title the past four seasons in a row, but woes in Cleveland have prevented an NCAA tournament appearance. This year they finished fourth after they lost six of eight games to close the regular season. Toledo hasn’t made the NCAA tournament since 1979-1980.  

Toledo started four sophomores, so you would think next year they should be much improved, being that they have much more experience. But with the transfer portal, you never know what could happen. After last season, Toledo lost three starters to the portal.

In some ways, it was a miracle Toledo finished the year 18-15. According to KenPom, Toledo finished the season last in the MAC in defensive efficiency and 7th in 3p%. Not a winning recipe.

Toledo men’s basketball will likely not play in a postseason tournament.

No. 2 Toledo begins to process their loss to #1 Ball State as they watch the Cardinals celebrate on court.

Toledo head coach Ginny Boggess watches down court as players react to a basket.

Khera Goss receives a pass and begins to drive up to the basket.

Toledo Blue Crew members (from left to right) Woozyy #128, Jammies #130, Heartthrob #134, Nutcracker #127, and Granny #129.

Toledo head coach Ginny Boggess goes over a play during a time out.

Toledo head coach Ginny Boggess questions Faith Fedd-Robinson about a foul.

Toledo’s Jessica Cook saves the ball from being out of bounds by tossing it to teammate Khera Goss.

The Toledo bench reacts to a foul on Sammi Mikonowicz.

Toledo Rockets cheer on Toledo during a foul shot.

Sammi Mikonowicz drives past Ball State’s Marie Kiefer.

Hannah Noveroske calls a play to her teammates while on the bench.

Khera Goss, Sammi Mikonowicz and Cadence Dykstra wait at half court as a Ball State player was tended to after a fall.

Rossford native and Toledo senior Sammi Mikonowicz, center, gets emotional after the team’s loss.

Sammi Mikonowicz, from left, Kendall Carruthers and Khera Goss wait for their coach to take them into the locker room after a heartbreaking defeat.

Sammi Mikonowicz, center, is escorted off of the court by teammates Faith Fedd-Robinson, left, and Kendall Carruthers after their loss to Ball State. Mikonowicz and Carruthers are both from the Toledo area.

Chorus frogs emerge in our metroparks

0
The first wave of chorus frogs has emerged and are singing for mates in our vernal pools. A wonderful place to hear them is along the Wabash-Cannonball Trail. (Courtesy Photo/Art Weber)

TOLEDO – Everywhere there are signs that Mother Nature is awakening from winter’s slumber. The timing is about right; On Thursday, March 20, the astronomical first day of spring is on the vernal equinox.

Most of the early signs are subtle – buds swelling, skunk cabbage emerging, eagles nesting. More obvious is the growing song along Metroparks Toledo’s Wabash-Cannonball Trail, where vernal pools are welcoming chorus frogs and spring peepers settle in and serenade the opposite sex with their song.

We’re just in the opening act of their performance. The two species are small and blend in well with their environment. They may be difficult to see, but their loud songs are distinctive and easy to identify. 

Chorus frogs have a loud quavering call, usually described as a fingernail running down a comb, only its tone and delivery can carry a kilometer away and it is heard day and night. In some Metroparks Toledo locations, approaching the pools can be deafening. 

Spring peepers use a single high peep, described as sweet and melodious.

Both species will be performing for several weeks. 

In future weeks, there will be others – 10 frog and toad species – each with its distinctive song. And then there will be our songbirds. 

There’s so much to look forward to on Metroparks Toledo trails. 

BGSU hires legend Eddie George & MAC tourney roundup

0

On The Flyby Sports Podcast, co-hosts and school rivals Chas McNeil and Max Alfonso dissect all of the matchups and schedules for the 2025 MAC Tournament on both the men’s and women’s sides.

For this episode, McNeil shares the news that Bowling Green has hired Ohio State and Tennessee Titan legend Eddie George to be their 21st head coach in program history, replacing Scot Loeffler, who left to pursue the quarterbacks coach job for the Philadelphia Eagles.

Main topic is MAC Tournament play and predictions, but they also recap the past two weeks of action for winter sports, including a playoff run by BGSU hockey and the start of MAC play for the baseball teams; and select their athletes of the week.

New episodes of the The Flyby Sports Podcast drop every Saturday.

The Flyby Sports Podcast is a production of the⁠⁠⁠⁠ Toledo Free Press⁠⁠⁠.

Football legend Eddie George hired as new BGSU head football coach

0
New BGSU head football coach Eddie George, center, answers questions from the media while university president Rodney K. Rogers, left, and athletic director Derek van der Merwe listen listen. (TFP Photo/Scott W. Grau)

BOWLING GREEN – A run-of-the-mill introductory press conference hosted a small crew of local journalists, all eager to ask questions about the future to the new coach. But the introduction of 1995 Heisman winner and new Bowling Green head coach Eddie George on March 10 was anything but run-of-the-mill.

In fact, it mirrored a red-carpet event with a heavy focus on George’s well-known accomplishments over his long and successful career.

George was joined by hundreds of adoring Bowling Green and Ohio State fans lined with pictures, jerseys and footballs, hoping they would be lucky enough to get as much as an initial signed on their memorabilia.

BGSU head football coach Eddie George speaks during a press conference on March 10. (TFP Photo/Scott W. Grau)

“I saw the news on Saturday morning and my jaw hit the floor,” exclaimed Falcon fan Steve Leid. “Then yesterday at work, a friend of mine got a notification on his phone saying that it was a done deal, and wow, there has just been a buzz in the air ever since.” 

Leid was clutching four images on printer paper; two were of the initial announcement released by BGSU and one was of a diving George hurdling a defender during his Ohio State days from 1992-1995. The final image was the most telling of the hire. It was a simple picture of George standing on the sidelines during his coaching time at Tennessee State University, which was the last place he coached, which was from 2021-2024.

Yes, the celebrity of the hire brings a lot of publicity to BGSU, as well as many recruits who will inevitably be excited to play for the all-time rushing leader for the NFL’s Tennessee Titans. 

What George did at Tennessee State was exactly what got him hired. Through his four years at TSU, he was able to accumulate back-to-back winning seasons for the first time since 2016-2017, in addition to making the FCS playoffs for the first time since 2013.

Urban Meyer and Dave Clawson both made the exact same remark to me, and I put this in my coaching profile: Someone who is always building on what we have and is not focused on what we don’t have,” BGSU’s athletic director Derek van der Merwe said.

New BGSU head football coach Eddie George, left, and athletic director Derek van der Merwe pose with a jersey.(TFP Photo/Scott W. Grau)

That was the key to this slam dunk hire by the Orange and Brown – someone who can succeed no matter the circumstances, a characteristic that George displayed time and time again in his playing and coaching career.

George’s first collegiate touchdown was scored in Columbus, Ohio against none other than the Falcons. With a mighty career sparked by that milestone at BGSU, it seemed almost fated that the legend would become a Falcon.

“It’s been so long…it was my freshman year and that was actually the touchdown that started ‘Touchdown Eddie.’ Flying in here to Ohio and coming back to this region, to this part of the country…it brought back just a rush of memories. The sunsets are different here and the community is so strong,” George said.

Despite saying he would embrace the state of Ohio, there was one crucial location in the state that the coach alluded to which would be a priority in the most hated way.

“I don’t embrace it,” he said about the Toledo rivalry. “There’s only one thing that we are going to do. Put that ball in the dirt and let them feel the iron fist,” George proclaimed.

The first true test for the Buckeye and Titans legend will be on Aug. 28 when the Falcons will play their first game of the 2025 season against Lafayette at Doyt L. Perry Stadium in Bowling Green.

To get a true taste of the rivalry, it will be a bit longer: The home game is scheduled for Oct. 11, the first time that George will battle his new “team up north.”

“What I do know is that we are going to play fast, we’ll be physical, we’ll be disciplined and we will let the scoreboard take care of itself,” George told the media, fans and BGSU. “That’s the goal; we will be physical.”

New BGSU head football coach Eddie George, center, answers questions from the media while university president Rodney K. Rogers, left, and athletic director Derek van der Merwe listen listen. (TFP Photo/Scott W. Grau)

Don Lee: Tariffs with Canada

0

Neezy’s Freezes serves Bowling Green

0
Neezy’s Freezes opened in October. It used to be Sundaze. (TFP Photos/Mary Helen DeLisle)

BOWLING GREEN If at first you don’t succeed, try, try again. Though perhaps cliché, this expression is proving true for Neezy’s Freezes, a new ice cream store in Bowling Green.

Neezy’s Freezes, formerly the ice cream shop Sundaze, opened in the fall, adding a new chapter to the ice cream venue’s history.

While to some it may seem strange to establish a new ice cream place in the same venue as one that previously failed, Neezy’s Freezes owner Deniz Ilgin is working to ensure Neezy’s is successful. 

Deniz Ilgin (TFP Photo/Mary Helen DeLisle)

Ilgin had the patio area renovated, the parking lot repaved, added to the kitchen and repainted and decorated the interior of the store. But renovations aren’t the only way Ilgin is setting Neezy’s Freezes apart from Sundaze. 

Ilgin has co-ownership with her parents, who also own Reynolds Garden Cafe in Toledo. Ilgin believes their experience and guidance will help set her business apart. 

“They have so much passion for what they do. That comes across in the food, which I think draws people in,” said Ilgin.

While the venue uses the ice cream machines previously used by Sundaze, Neezy’s Freezes offers more than just ice cream, serving coffee drinks, hot dogs, burgers, barbequed beef, french fries, cookies, cakes and more. 

Despite all of Ilgin’s hard work, starting a small business is not without its challenges.

According to the Chamber of Commerce, 18 percent of small businesses close within their first year, 50 percent close after five years, and approximately 65 percent close by their 10th year in business.   

While this could be seen as a bleak statistic, Ryan Holley, assistant professor in the College of Business at Bowling Green State University and small business owner, said small business closure or failure is not always because a business couldn’t establish itself; sometimes it’s because the owner is more interested in maximizing profit than in establishing a community staple. 

“The small business owner might have a mom-and-pop restaurant, and that’s their entire character, what defines them as a person. Their identity is in this restaurant, where the entrepreneur is just OK. It’s an asset. Let’s sell it,” Holley said. 

Ilgin falls into the former category, meaning her desire for the business’s longevity could improve her chances of success.

“I had always worked in my parents’ restaurant, and I really liked that. I liked being able to talk to people and have interpersonal interactions every day instead of being at a desk. And I really like the community that you can build when you own your own business,” Ilgin said. 

Holley also highlighted why small businesses may have a tougher time succeeding than large corporations. 

“When you take on ownership of a small business, you are responsible for everything. You are the marketing department, the human resources, the operations, the finance. Larger businesses have an ability to attract specialized talent,” Holley said.

“Whereas a small business, you don’t have that, and you might not have access to the same education or depth of knowledge,” he noted.

Neezy’s Freezes is located at 21018 Haskins Rd. More information about the restaurant can be found on their Facebook and Instagram pages.

Op-ed: Outlining problems with CCNO as ICE detention center

0
The Corrections Center of Northwest Ohio (CCNO) in Stryker, Ohio.

The Corrections Center of Northwest Ohio is set to become an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detention center. Below are a few things I think the jail board should have been told before voting.

ICE’s rhetoric labels every immigrant a criminal, but sheriffs already have the authority to arrest people who commit crimes; they do this every day. And while the vast majority of the people who commit crimes are U.S. citizens, of course law enforcement arrests people born in other countries. What the jail board voted to do instead is to start incarcerating people who are not accused of crimes. 

ICE detention is technically “civil” confinement, but it takes place in a criminal jail. You read that right. ICE is one of the few agencies that has the authority to put people in criminal jails while they are navigating a civil legal process. They have the authority but they don’t need to use it. It’s a choice made through political considerations rather than what’s good for our communities.

Incarcerating someone is a serious decision. It’s separation from their family, job and home. If it seems inhumane to put people navigating a civil process in a criminal jail, that’s because it is. 

During the first Trump administration, the Ohio Immigrant Alliance worked with Ohio families dealing with a loved one’s detention and deportation. Maryam Sy interviewed 255 individuals and we wrote a book about their experiences with Suma Setty at the Center for Law and Social Policy.

We talked to fathers whose children became depressed, and even suicidal, after their parents were detained. We talked to mothers trying to hold down jobs and care for young children while they worried about the future of their families. We talked to families in foreclosure. We saw loving relationships fracture due to the stress of detention and deportation. We talked to men who were deported in straight jackets, unable to make themselves board a plane to a country that had tortured them.

These Ohioans had been in the U.S. for 10 and 20 years or more. Some fled genocide. Some had been able to buy homes, open businesses and even employ Americans. These are the people CCNO is agreeing to detain and help deport. As Lucas County Sheriff Mike Navarre said, when announcing his opposition to the ICE contract, “Nobody has a viable solution to what will happen to these children. Until they figure it out, I will not support mass deportations.”

Another thing to know is that people can simultaneously be eligible for deportation and eligible for a green card. For example, many of the people we work with are married to U.S. citizens. They applied for green cards and are waiting for the process to conclude — that can take decades because of how our laws were designed. The government has a choice about whether to allow them to continue to pursue that status, or put them in line for deportation. During the first Trump administration, and now in the second, the government chose the path of breaking up families. 

Finally, the CCNO board should have been told that immigration detention is indefinite. There’s no time-limited “sentence” like in a criminal case. Executive director Dennis Sullivan told board members that the average length of stay would be 40-45 days. But that is based on Biden-era figures, which included people who were deported quickly at the border.

That’s not how the Trump administration operates. They are arresting people who can’t immediately be deported, like people who have appeals pending. According to the American Immigration Council, people with cases in immigration court are often held for six months or longer.

During the first Trump administration, we worked with individuals who were detained for 12 months or more — some up to four years — in Ohio county jails. These jails are not set up for long-term incarceration. But, they are required to provide medical care. The Butler and Morrow County jails tried to scrimp on medical costs and were sued. Judge Sarah D. Morrison, a Trump-appointee, blasted the Morrow Jail for creating an “unconstitutionally acceptable environment,” in a case brought by the ACLU of Ohio. 

Earlier this year, the ACLU of Ohio and other organizations sent a letter to counties outlining their legal obligations under ICE contracts. It doesn’t appear that anyone, other than Sheriff Navarre and Lucas County Commissioner Pete Gerken, read it. A 2020 lawsuit against Butler County Jail, which is based on civil rights violations by corrections officers, remains pending

The CCNO board will soon find itself at the center of family separations. It’s not too late to choose a different path, one that focuses on local needs, instead of engaging in a federal political battle that will harm our community members.

Everyone in Ohio — whether we were born here or somewhere else — wants the same thing. To live in a safe place and take care of our families. Said an Ohio father who was deported after months in an Ohio county jail, “I’m a human, like everybody else. Nobody [is] better than nobody, man.”