I will never forget the day that my best friend and I discovered Alanis Morissette’s hidden track on the genre-defining, internationally acclaimed album, Jagged Little Pill.
Caity and I would pop in our Jagged CD and drive around for hours listening to the album’s poignant lyricism and striking instrumentals, singing at the top of our lungs until we’d finish the final track, “You Oughta Know (Jimmy the Saint Blend),” and start it over again.
One day we were having a particularly hard day dealing with our adolescent angst, so we pulled into a parking lot and talked out our problems underscored by the album. When it finished, instead of starting the album over, we found the final track on the list kept playing only to reveal the most gut-wrenching, intensely vulnerable song we’d ever heard: “Your House.”
The album was already a core part of our lives, but in that moment, we felt like everything was going to be okay, and we discovered that Jagged Little Pill is the gift that keeps on giving.
Enter: Jagged Little Pill (musical). The show follows the Healy family, all navigating their own strife with one central plotline that could change the family’s lives forever. The best part? The show is a jukebox style musical set to Alanis’ iconic album, padded with a few of her other hits, and featuring two songs written by Alanis for the musical.

This show is no easy feat to produce, but unsurprisingly, Stone Productions was up to the task. Let me set the scene of the roadblocks:
On the technical side, our production team had to create an airtight vision, as this is the northwest Ohio premiere of the show. Though minimal set pieces, Jagged has no time for scene changes, instead relying on stellar lighting (thank you Zann Campbell-Johannes!) and four panels to shift through the non-stop show. The show is ensemble-heavy, so our sound designer had his work cut out for him navigating cues and balance (shoutout Roger Flanagan!). On the performer side, there’s necessary trigger warnings for serious subject matter, which sets our team up for an emotional journey, combined with the physical and vocal demands that are nearly unheard of in live theatre.
Then there’s the choreography of the show, which is where I come in. Aside from the incomparable music of Alanis and the deeply important storylines, Jagged Little Pill does something extremely uncommon in musical theatre: It uses choreography to further the plot.

I knew this would be unlike anything I’ve choreographed, and not just from the pressure of using dance as an actual plot device and combining 90s influence and lyrical expression. It wasn’t even the daunting task of choreographing 14 of the 23 songs on the album; rather, the biggest challenge was encouraging this group to develop a comfortableness with their bodies to be vulnerable on stage and engage with freestyle.
Our production team was so fortunate to work with some of the most talented humans. The principal actors are amazing, armed with complex, diverse characters. Our ensemble is just as crucial as these leading characters. They took my giant ask, and delivered to the umpteenth degree.
But I would be remiss if I didn’t wax poetic about my avatars.
This show features a few select dancers assigned to different characters in the show who have the hard job of showing how our leads are feeling emotionally. Ciara Lieberman (MJ’s avatar), Chanel Black (Frankie’s avatar), Callum Mather (Nick’s avatar), and myself (Bella’s avatar), have worked tirelessly to understand these characters and execute some demanding choreography, all while being in the ensemble as well.

There’s no other combination of humans that could’ve produced what our production team put together. Our crew, including Ben Salati and Brad Arps, hustled beyond belief, under the direction of our bright and meticulous stage manager Marian Marlatt. Our music director and beloved friend Kevin McGill expertly taught songs that had most individuals tackling their own harmonies, compiled and leading musicians for the pit, and didn’t even break a sweat.
This is the fourth show I’ve choreographed alongside Co-Director Jaymes Gregory-Mull, whose reputation of putting on incredible productions precedes him. He was bold enough to choose this show, and knocked his vision out of the park, along with any roadblocks that stood in our way (even if it meant he had to wear multiple hats as director/stage crew/cast).

I’m lucky that Co-Director Andronicus Roberts, or my “little brother” as he’s affectionately known, got to work together. Not only did Andy take on co-directing this show, but he also had the security and self-awareness to play Andrew, the show’s central villain, and my dance partner for one of the most pivotal moments of the show. Though I could go on and on about this team, I will simply say I am so grateful for the opportunity to work with them.
But what makes this experience one of the most memorable of my time as a choreographer is performing alongside my best friend, Caity. More than 10 years since we discovered “Your House” on a random weekday, I now get to hear Caity sing this song every night as Jo. I’ll find myself at rehearsals catching glimpses of our teen selves, unsure about what the world holds, but knowing that as long as we have each other, “Everything’s gonna be fine, fine, fine.” That’s the impact of Jagged Little Pill, and the magic of Alanis.
Jagged Little Pill runs at the Collingwood Arts Center July 24, 25 and Aug. 1 at 8 p.m., and Aug. 2 at 3 p.m. Viewer discretion is advised. Find your tickets here.


































